Friday, May 20, 2022
  • Hype
  • Murai
  • Lipstiq
  • Diva
  • Varnam
  • Moviedash
  • Autofreaks
Lowyat.NET
  • News
    • Lifestyle
    • Computing
    • Hardware
    • Internet
    • Rumours & Leaks
    • Software
  • Forums
    • Kopitiam
    • Tradezone
    • Property Talk
    • Finance & Business
    • Fast and Furious
  • Gaming
    • PC Gaming
    • Console
    • Esports
  • Mobile
    • Apps
    • OS
    • Tablets
    • Phones
    • Telco
      • Celcom
      • DiGi
      • Maxis
      • Tune Talk
      • U Mobile
      • Buzzme
  • Pricelists
    • Hardware
      • Compu-zone
      • Viewnet
      • Thundermatch
      • Sri Computers
    • Notebooks
      • Compu-zone
    • Smartphones
      • Thundermatch
  • More
    • Automotive Tech
    • Drone
    • Enterprise
    • Entertainment
    • Fashion
    • E-Hailing
    • Wearables
No Result
View All Result
Lowyat.NET
  • News
    • Lifestyle
    • Computing
    • Hardware
    • Internet
    • Rumours & Leaks
    • Software
  • Forums
    • Kopitiam
    • Tradezone
    • Property Talk
    • Finance & Business
    • Fast and Furious
  • Gaming
    • PC Gaming
    • Console
    • Esports
  • Mobile
    • Apps
    • OS
    • Tablets
    • Phones
    • Telco
      • Celcom
      • DiGi
      • Maxis
      • Tune Talk
      • U Mobile
      • Buzzme
  • Pricelists
    • Hardware
      • Compu-zone
      • Viewnet
      • Thundermatch
      • Sri Computers
    • Notebooks
      • Compu-zone
    • Smartphones
      • Thundermatch
  • More
    • Automotive Tech
    • Drone
    • Enterprise
    • Entertainment
    • Fashion
    • E-Hailing
    • Wearables
No Result
View All Result
Lowyat.NET
No Result
View All Result
Home Editorial

[Opinion] Why Mobile Phone Benchmarks Don’t Tell You Anything About A Phone

by Lucas Lau
October 2, 2013
Samsung Caught Boosting Benchmark Results for Note 3, Increase Scores by 20 Percent
72
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Samsung Boost Benchmark on Note 3 1

In light of this morning’s news about Samsung modifying some code to boost their benchmark results for the Galaxy Note 3, giving a 20% increase in scores, I got thinking, are benchmarks THAT important anyway?. This is not the first time they have been “caught” doing so as well; When their flagship Galaxy S4 came out, they also boosted their CPU and GPU clock speeds in hopes for those bigger numbers. Shame on Samsung right? Wrong. Shame on anyone who actually thinks that a phone’s benchmark score on AnTuTu or Quadrant actually means anything when you’re choosing a phone.

Article continues after the jump

iphone-5s-21-600x452

 

 

This phenomenon is not just confined to the Android ecosystem. When the iPhone 5S first came out, the Internet was rife with praise on how it “slaughters quad-core rivals in performance tests despite dual-core CPU and just 1GB of RAM” According to BGR and Anandtech, 2 very esteemed publications, the Sunspider and Google Octane tests showed that the iPhone beat out all rivals with a fairly wide margin. This is thanks to the 64-bit A7 chip in the new phone, after all it was said to be 31% faster than the A6 and up to 40x faster (according to one of their slides). Well of course it is.

iphone2013-0152

Credit: Engadget Live Blog Coverage

No phone manufacturer in the world would release a new product which is slower than its predecessor. Let’s look for a second at that graph. 40x faster than what, the original iPhone? That’s a terrible comparison at best. BGR and Anandtech are doing awesome work with what they are writing and the tests they do, but I think benchmarks and numbers are doing more harm than good in the world of the smartphone.

3SLI_GTX280_m

ADVERTISEMENT

Photo Source: VR Zone

Now I’m not calling into question the practice of benchmarking in general because let’s face it, if you’re a PC guy who takes pride in building a PC from scratch whether it be for overclocking or just hardcore gaming, benchmarks are everything. With the tweaking of your clock speed, upping of your voltage or even swapping parts out gives a difference in your overall hardware benchmark and could mean the difference between an unstable 120fps, smooth 80fps or jittery 60.

Skins

Smartphones are not desktop PCs. In a desktop PC environment, the experience doesn’t change, the OS is pretty much the same across the versions and the usability is confined to what parts you choose and what input peripherals you choose. This is where benchmarking can determine which PC is better. Higher numbers = better parts for the most part. For a smartphone, where there is way more to the device than just what powers it is a whole different ballgame.

n9-iphone41

 

It’s an iPhone 4 but you get the point

Let’s go back to the iPhone 5S example: While its true and undisputed that the phone is obliterating its rivals in Sunspider and Octane, but that speaks NOTHING for how good the phone is. iOS and Android are 2 intrinsically different operating systems and user experiences. How can one compare which is better based on how fast they crunch numbers? Let’s bring the Nokia N9 into the picture. Hardware from 2009 will never beat the newest phones now, but let’s look at the user experience. Some will tell you that the N9 still had one of the first gesture based operating systems which predated lots of modern OS’ features. MeeGo was a truly intuitive operating system, unluckily cut short. Now just because it couldn’t rock a good Sunspider score, does that make it worse than an iPhone? Heck no. Pang sure doesn’t think so.

130918_iphone_5s_a7_speed

So the next time you read a review about a phone, try to keep the benchmarks to a “FYI” sort of thing. Whether or not a phone is good is down to which operating system you prefer, if you like the build of the device and nowadays, how well the camera performs. In your time with your current phone, I’m pretty sure no one has ever thought “I wish that my Galaxy S4 had 1000 more points on AnTuTu, that would make it a whole lot better”. Granted it is a good indication of how fast certain applications will open or run, but that in itself is not the be all and end all. Read about the build, first impressions and the gripes my fellow writers and I have with the devices and soon, you’ll have your answer to your questions without even having to worry about a single benchmark.

I’d like to know what you think; If you’re reading the benchmarks first for a smartphone, what is your thought process? Is it purely to see how fast it will run apps? Have you bought a phone purely based on benchmarks? Leave a comment below!

Tags: AnTuTuBenchmarkiPhone 5SN9PhoneSamsung
Back to top
Share2Tweet1SendShare

ADVERTISEMENT

RELATED ARTICLES

realme pad x china announced
Tablets

realme Pad X Unveiled; Launching In China Next Week

by Heirul Kamel
May 20, 2022

realme China has announced that it will be releasing yet another device to its tablet lineup this year. Unlike the...

Read more
OPPO Pad Air China
Tablets

OPPO Unveils Its Second Tablet, The OPPO Pad Air

by Heirul Kamel
May 19, 2022

OPPO officially entered the tablet market last February when it launched its first-ever tablet, the OPPO Pad. It now appears...

Read more
whatsapp exit group
Apps

WhatsApp Will Soon Let You Leave Groups Quietly

by Ikmal Rozlan
May 18, 2022

WhatsApp is apparently working on a new feature that will delight users who feel that they have been added into...

Read more
MySejahtera Infectious Disease Tracker
Apps

MySejahtera’s Infectious Disease Tracker Adds Tuberculosis Cases

by Ikmal Rozlan
May 18, 2022

As part of the government's move to transition MySejahtera into a post-pandemic public health tool, it has converted the app’s...

Read more
Load More
No Result
View All Result

TRENDING TODAY

  1. 1
    Data Breaches

    Another JPN Database Appears Online With An Asking Price Of Almost RM44,000

  2. 2
    Mobile Phones

    OPPO Find X5 Pro Goes Official In Malaysia For RM4,999

  3. 3
    Fintech

    You Can Now Terminate Touch n Go RFID Tag Online

  4. 4
    News

    Amazon Web Services To Develop Data Centres In Malaysia

  5. 5
    Random

    IT Admin Imprisoned Seven Years For Wiping Out Company Servers

Lowyat.NET

Consumer Tech News & Reviews Malaysia

NETWORK

  • Hype
  • Murai
  • Lipstiq
  • Diva
  • Varnam
  • Moviedash
  • Autofreaks

ABOUT

  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Privacy Statement
  • Contact Us
  • Editorial Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

©2022 LOWYAT MEDIA, LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Lifestyle
    • Computing
    • Hardware
    • Internet
    • Rumours & Leaks
    • Software
  • Forums
    • Kopitiam
    • Tradezone
    • Property Talk
    • Finance & Business
    • Fast and Furious
  • Gaming
    • PC Gaming
    • Console
    • Esports
  • Mobile
    • Apps
    • OS
    • Tablets
    • Phones
    • Telco
      • Celcom
      • DiGi
      • Maxis
      • Tune Talk
      • U Mobile
      • Buzzme
  • Pricelists
    • Hardware
      • Compu-zone
      • Viewnet
      • Thundermatch
      • Sri Computers
    • Notebooks
      • Compu-zone
    • Smartphones
      • Thundermatch
  • More
    • Automotive Tech
    • Drone
    • Enterprise
    • Entertainment
    • Fashion
    • E-Hailing
    • Wearables

©2022 LOWYAT MEDIA, LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Learn More.